Healthy Holistic Living
Advertisement

New Studies Show Humans Love Dogs More Than Other Humans

Dogs, Dog Hugs loading...


Consider this scenario: both a dog and a human being are standing side-by-side, facing a harmful event in which they both need help in order to remain unharmed. While you would surely like to assist both, you are only able to help one of them. Which do you choose? This decision would understandably be difficult to make, since both are at varying abilities to defend themselves as well as at varying levels of cuteness.

However surprising or unsurprising it may be, however, studies have clearly revealed that when it comes down to empathetic situations, the majority of people choose to help the dog over the person (1).

Does Your Friend Love Their Dog More Than You? 

Many people openly admit that they prefer their dogs to human beings. According to Sigmund Freud, “Dogs love their friends and bite their enemies, quite unlike people, who are incapable of pure love and always have to mix love and hate” (2). Faced with this interesting phenomenon, sociologists and anthropologists from Northeastern University and the University of Colorado decided to scientifically investigate why such a strong bond exists between people and their cuddly pooches (1). They wondered why it was that when a report of an animal in need made headlines, the overflow of response was often much higher than when similar headlines hit the news concerning human impact.

Advertisement

In order to investigate the situation, researchers asked 256 college students to read a fictitious report about a brutally beaten adult or child versus a report relaying a similarly abused dog or puppy (1). All of their reactions of empathy were measured in order to reveal some striking results: more empathy was clearly displayed for a canine of any age than for an adult human (1). According to the study, “We…found more empathy for victims who are human children, puppies, and fully-grown dogs than for victims who are adult humans. Age makes a difference for empathy toward human victims, but not for dog victims” (1).

Age Does Matter

The actual order of empathy was highest for the puppy, with the human baby coming in second, the adult dog in third, and the adult human far in last place (3). Female participants were far more empathetic towards all victims in general(4).

Advertisement

According to the researchers, “Our results indicate a much more complex situation with respect to the age and the species of victims, with age being the more important component. The fact that adult crime victims receive less empathy than do child, puppy, and full-grown dog victims suggest that adult dogs are also regarded as dependent and vulnerable, not unlike their younger canine counterparts and kids” (4).

Ultimately, it seems that we are much more likely to feel empathy for helpless victims who are unable to properly defend or look after themselves, such as infants and toddlers, than we are to feel empathy for adult victims capable of handling themselves (4). According to this research, we apparently view puppies and dogs under the same light, deserving of similar amounts of empathy and protection (4).

The Hero Complex

While it’s obvious that people create bonds and develop feelings of love quite strongly between themselves and other human beings, the research reveals that when given a choice, one is much more likely to defend and assist those who are incapable of defending and helping themselves. While two adults can certainly communicate in ways impossible for infants and dogs to, the mere fact that babies, puppies, and adult dogs are vulnerable makes them much more likely to earn the empathy of an onlooker.

So consider the scenario: both a dog and human being are in need of your help, and you can only help one. Statistics and evidence aside, which do you choose?

By Abbey Ryan-Elder

Jenna Barrington

Jenna Barrington

Jenna is a writer, entrepreneur and the CEO of The Hired Pen. She has been working as a freelance writer and blog manager for many years. Jenna has a degree in Nutritional Health Counseling and extensive training as a copywriter and in search engine optimization. She has always had a passion for writing and loves to create space for people to express their passions, inner thoughts and voices through the written word. Jenna is dedicated to providing audiences around the world
with high-quality content that is research-based, well thought out and designed to create positive impact. When she is not writing, Jenna loves spending time with her daughter and their golden retriever exploring the outdoors, eating at Asian restaurants, doing martial arts, or drinking milkshakes while watching comedies. If you want to reach Jenna personally you can email her at jenna.barrington27@gmail.com.
Jenna Barrington

A Quick Note from Our Founder

Have you been curious about losing weight eating Bacon and Butter? You're not alone!

Going "Keto" has helped so many of my friends drop weight and keep it off.

And it's the perfect time to try it because right now you can get a free copy of a brand new cookbook called The Bacon and Butter Cookbook

This cookbook is jampacked with 148 delicious ketogenic recipes that will help you burn fat like crazy. Even stubborn belly and thigh fat won't stand a chance because your body will have NO CHOICE but to burn that fat for fuel!

If you've struggled to get rid of stubborn fat, you owe it to yourself to test-drive the keto diet and see how effective it really is. It’ll be easy once you have this free cookbook…

HURRY, this FREE offer won’t last long!

GET THE FREE COOKBOOK
sponsored advertisement
Advertisement